Skip to main content

Pizza is the favorite food of Americans across the country, according to a recent survey. Beating out steak, hamburgers, tacos, and pasta, pizza is the reigning champ of the American diet.

In fact, more than 41% of Americans eat pizza at least once a week, and on any given day one out of every eight Americans is enjoying a slice.

More than 10% of all of the pizzerias in the United States are located in New York City. Famous for its New York-style pizza, you might be wondering if you have to take a trip to the Big Apple to enjoy this legacy of Italian American culture.

If you’re finding yourself searching “Boise Pizza” in a quest for New York style pies, you’re in luck. At Wiseguy Pizza Pie, we offer the best New York-style pizza west of the Mississippi. Not only that, but our vast menu accommodates just about every diet so that your whole family can enjoy an incredible, piping hot slice tonight.

We Are Committed to Quality

You’ll find that a lot of pizza places are always cutting corners. Not at Wiseguy.

Every day, we make our dough and our sauce fresh. Our pies are hand-tossed before being baked to perfection in stone deck ovens. Where other pizza places are cutting corners, we go the extra mile to make sure that every single pie fulfills the epitome of excellence.

We Make New York Style Pizza

Everyone loves pizza, and New York City is world-famous for its thin-crust pizza that developed from the Neapolitan-style meals of the city’s early 20th century, Italian immigrants. You can get a taste of the big city all the way out west in the Boise area when you stop by one of Wiseguy’s three locations.

Whether you are in Boise, Hailey, or Ketchum, you can find New York-style Pizza at Wiseguy Pizza Pie. Our crust is thin and wide, made possible by our use of stone decks.

Want to know more about New York-style pizza? Check out this article!

There Are Options for Every Diet

At most pizza places, people who are vegan and gluten-free are often out of luck if they hope to enjoy some fresh, delicious pies. Sure, they might be able to get a salad, but that’s hardly what most people are looking for when they are ordering from a pizza place.

According to the CDC, about 17.1% of American adults over the age of 20 subscribe to a special diet on any given day. Whether you’re counting calories, trying to avoid gluten, or cutting out animal products, we are here to make sure that you are well fed no matter your dietary needs and preferences.

We Offer Vegan Options

We offer nondairy mozzarella for people who subscribe to a vegan diet to ensure that everyone can get the pizza experience they are looking for. We also offer plenty of incredible veggie topping options, meaning that you don’t have to stick with plain cheese unless that is your preference.

Vegans and vegetarians alike will delight at our topping options. You can choose to add fresh basil, mushrooms, garlic, spinach, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, pineapple, arugula, artichokes, and so much more when you “make your own” pizza.

There are a lot of benefits to eating a vegan diet, including allowing you to enjoy foods that are richer in certain nutrients, helping you lose weight, and even protecting you from the risk of serious, chronic diseases. Whether you are a strict vegan or you simply prefer to go meat-free some days, it’s important that all of us have access to delicious, nutritious, fresh vegetables.

Whether you want to try one of our amazing salads or go for a vegan pizza pie, Wiseguy Pizza Pie won’t disappoint the vegan in your life. We offer the same great taste of traditional pizza without anyone having to compromise their values or their diet.

Many of our fancy pies are already vegetarian and can easily be adjusted for a vegan diet. All you have to do is ask!

We Offer Gluten-Free Options

On top of that, we also have gluten-free cauliflower crust. Whether you have celiac disease or you are avoiding gluten for other reasons, you can still enjoy any of our incredible pizzas without having to consume any gluten. Available in a 10″ pie, this cauliflower crust might also be suitable for those subscribing to a low-carb diet.

We know, we know. Sometimes gluten-free replacements for usually glutenous foods can be pretty disappointing. If you’re skeptical that our gluten-free crust is going to quench your pizza thirst, all you have to do is take a look at our reviews. One recent reviewer, for example, remarked that we had the “best gluten-free pizzas” they’d ever tasted.

Even if you don’t have a gluten allergy, there are a number of known benefits to following a gluten-free diet. Research has found that it can help with insulin control as well as weight loss. On top of that, it can help to give you an energy boost.

All of your favorite toppings are still available when you choose a gluten-free crust. This means that you don’t have to feel left out on pizza night at home or when you’re hanging out with your friends watching the super bowl. Gone are the days of having to get a salad when everyone else is enjoying a fresh, incredible slice!

Are you curious to learn more about the benefits of enjoying gluten-free pizza? If so, take a look at this article with the top ten benefits.

We Use Local, Fresh Ingredients

In our culture, pizza gets a bad rap. At Wiseguy Pizza Pie, we’re here to change the way you think about pizza. Our ingredients are fresh and local, meaning that our pies are a far cry from many other pizza places.

The flour that we used is provided by Pendleton Power Flour, which primarily uses Pocatello Idaho farms in order to produce their grains. A lot of times, when restaurants claim to use local ingredients they are only highlighting a handful of what’s offered on their menu. At Wiseguy, even the crust of your pizza is sourced locally.

Our whole-milk mozzarella is sourced out of Jerome, Idaho. We are committed to using local ingredients because they tend to be fresher, tastier, and better for you. On top of that, as a small local business, we are dedicated to helping our local economy thrive and keeping money in our local community.

When we use local ingredients, it also means that a lot less fuel is used to deliver the ingredients to our stores. This means that eating local isn’t just fresher, tastier, and better for you, but it’s also better for the environment.

The list of reasons to buy local goes on and on. Not only does local food look and taste better, but it also gives you that unique kind of assurance that lets you know the food you’re eating is safe. We tell you exactly where we source our ingredients from, meaning you are more than welcome to check out these local farmers and producers if you’re curious about their products and practices.

Local food is also a great way to build community. Over the last many decades, food production has been getting farther and farther away from the people who are eating it. By engaging in the local food economy, we help to build community by getting to know local farmers and connecting them with you, the customer.

Lastly, well-managed farms are hugely beneficial for wildlife and the environment. When farms are well-sized and well-managed, they protect water sources, conserve fertile soil, and sequester carbon from the atmosphere. The environment created by smaller farms produces a patchwork of meadows, fields, ponds, and woods that provide a place for wildlife in our communities to live.

To learn more about the benefits of local foods, take a look at this article.

We Offer Half Baked Pies for You to Bake at Home

Getting pizza for take-out can be an awesome choice for dinner, but sometimes it doesn’t time out so your pie is still pleasantly hot at the time you’re ready to eat dinner. At Wiseguy Pizza Pie, we’re committed to ensuring that you never suffer the fate of eating cold pizza (unless, of course, that’s something you’re into.)

That’s why we offer half-baked pies so that you can finish baking them at your leisure. Whether it’s on your way to pick up Wiseguy Pizza earlier in the day for tonight’s dinner, or you simply aren’t sure when dinner time will roll around, this is the perfect solution to make sure that your pizza night is as perfect as it should be.

We Offer Daily Specials

Every day, we offer new specials that give you an opportunity to try out different menu items for a deal. While we’re here to provide you with a dependable, consistent, and delicious pizza place for all of your needs, we also recognize the drive to try something new every once in a while. Be sure to check out our board to find out the specials of the day or ask one of our friendly staff on the phone about our specials.

We Have Three Locations

Whether you live right in downtown Boise or east of the city near 75, Wiseguy Pizza has convenient locations so you can get your pizza fixed any time, anywhere.

Each location has its own menu to suit local tastes. At each of our locations, you can choose from a wide array of appetizers and salads, delicious sandwiches and calzones, real fancy pies, and build your own pizzas. If you’re feeling thirsty for a delightful craft beer, microbrew, or glass of wine, we’ve got you covered.

We don’t like to brag, but it’s important that you understand what you’re missing out on if you’ve never been to Wiseguy Pizza Pie. One recent reviewer called it “honestly the best pizza in Idaho,” which is a compliment we humbly accept.

We Consider You to Be Family

Have you ever gone into a restaurant only to find that the staff is cold, uninterested, and seemingly inconvenienced by your presence? That’s no way to treat your guests. At Wiseguy, we truly count you, our loving customers, as part of the family.

Whether you are spending a Friday or Saturday night out with your friends or bringing a half-baked pizza home to-go, we welcome you into our Wiseguy family. The tradition of authentic Italian cooking is close to our heart, and that works hand in hand with Italian familial hospitality.

That’s part of the reason why our prices are so affordable. We’re not here to nickel and dime you. We just really want to share our love of pizza pies with the rest of you.

We will warn you though: you’ll want to come hungry. While some restaurants might think it’s trendy to offer tiny portions for tons of money, we offer portions that aren’t for the faint of heart.

We Offer Outdoor Dining Options

If you’re in the mood for a depressing statistic, we’re here to let you know that the average American spends 90% of their time indoors. When it comes to your free time, do you really want to be hanging out inside?

No, we didn’t think so. When the sun is shining and the weather is pleasant, we all would rather spend our time outdoors. That’s why we offer outdoor seating options so you can get fresh air and sunshine whenever you please.

Our Boise location is located in the heart of downtown, but that doesn’t mean we keep you locked up inside. Instead, we have a patio area outside where you can enjoy the gorgeous Idaho weather while having a delicious drink and fresh slices of pizza pie.

Wiseguy Pizza Pie Delivers Fresh Pizza to Your Home

There are countless reasons why ordering delivery makes sense. Whether you’re planning on having a relaxing night in with your significant other or you’re in a bind when it comes to dinner plans, delivery can be the easy option you’re looking for.

Getting delivery can be a huge time-saver. Not only does cooking and cleaning up afterward take way longer than any of us would hope, but even picking up take-out can end up taking more time than you expect. When you order delivery, it’s a set-it and forget-it type option.

All you have to do is call to order or use our easy ordering feature online. Then sit back, relax, and wait for your hot, delicious, fresh New York-style pizza to arrive at your home.

Pizza is also the perfect option when you are feeding a crowd with diverse tastes. It’s hard to find someone who doesn’t like pizza, and we have options for people of every type of diet whether they are vegan or gluten-free.

When you order delivery from Wiseguy, your pizza arrives hot and fresh. If you pick up pizza from a restaurant, sometimes it can be disappointing to find how much it has cooled down in the time it took to drive home. When you get pizza delivered to your door, it arrives piping hot and ready to eat.

Do you need more convincing that delivery is the way to go? If so, check out this article.

Our Slices Are Huge

Have you ever gone out for pizza and been disappointed by the wimpy size of each slice? At Wiseguy, you don’t have to worry about that. We know that New York-style pizza means huge slices, and we go the extra mile when it comes to size.

We’re Here to Quench Your Thirst

Is there anything better than a delicious, cold craft beer along with a piping hot slice of pizza? No, we didn’t think so.

When it comes to our beer menu, we make sure that your options are as varied as they are when it comes to our food menu. We specialize in featuring the finest microbrews you can find in the Northwest, and we are constantly rotating our brews to give you as much variety as possible.

We also have a rotating wine list if you’re not in the mood for brews. And don’t worry, we haven’t forgotten about you gluten-free folks. Not only do we serve delicious cider options, but we also have gluten-free beer.

This last point might seem too good to be true, but we promise we wouldn’t lie to you. We don’t just deliver pizza, but we’ll also deliver you a beer. That’s right: when you order delivery from us, you can meet both your pizza and beer needs at the same time.

We’re Here to Make Dinner Time Easy, Every Time

Do you ever feel like it’s a bit much that we have to make ourselves dinner every day? With all of the other responsibilities that we have in our work and personal lives, sometimes the last thing you want to do when you get home is start cooking a fresh meal from scratch.

The other options are often dismal, though. You could choose to eat something depressing like ramen or a frozen pizza, but you deserve better than that. These days, ordering take-out from a restaurant is expensive enough that you practically have to consult your financial advisor to determine whether or not you can afford the investment.

If you find yourself in this type of bind, you don’t have to worry. Whether you find yourself impossibly busy or if you simply don’t want to cook, our three convenient locations make it easy to get Wiseguy pies any night of the week.

We also know how important it is to know when your food is going to be ready after you order it. For that reason, we always include an estimated wait time so you know exactly what to expect. We also accept Visa, Mastercard, and Amex to ensure that paying is easy and stress-free.

Come for the Best Local Pizza, Stay for the Atmosphere

While it might be our Boise, Idaho pizza that convinces you to stop by for the first time, it will be the welcoming atmosphere that convinces you to stay and keep coming back for more.

Our staff is friendly, our music is always on-point, and our vibe is both relaxed and lively at the same time. No wonder so many reviewers mention our awesome atmosphere after they finish singing the praises of our delicious local pizza.

Whether you visit our Boise location, our Hailey location, or our Ketchum location, you’ll find Wiseguy Pizza Pie to be a social and laidback place to hang out. Whether you’re out on the town with your significant other or spending an afternoon with the family, a stop at Wiseguy is always a good idea.

Wiseguy Pie: Your Go-To Spot For Pizza in Boise

Whether you’re looking to hang out in our awesome shop, take pizza home for dinner, or order delivery, Wiseguy offers the best Pizza in Boise. We’re here to serve you incredible, fresh pizza every day whether you are a meat lover, vegetarian, vegan, or you’ve been staying away from gluten.

You don’t have to fly into JFK to get your New York-style pizza fix anymore. Instead, you can head to one of our three convenient locations and enjoy some delicious, thin-crust pizza right here in the Rockies.

Hungry yet? If so, order pizza from us online here!

Leave a Reply