Skip to main content

The average person eats 6,000 slices of pizza in their lifetime. If you’re going to eat that much pizza, you want it to be delicious. That’s why finding the best place to order your pie is so important. 

If you find yourself passing a Pizza Pie restaurant, pull over as quickly as you can. The pizza here is both classic and unique, and there’s something on the menu to please every palate.

From mouthwatering toppings to perfectly turned-out crust, our pizza pie menu is packed with choices for everyone. Keep reading to find out why you need to make it your next pizza destination.

Types of Pizza

Wiseguy pizza pie offers several types of pizza for you to choose from, including traditional pizza and gluten-free pizza made with a delicious cauliflower crust. 

The traditional pizzas are available in 14-inch or 18-inch sizes. The gluten-free version is available in a 10-inch size. 

No matter which type you choose, the pizza pie toppings are plentiful. You can choose from a pre-made pie or mix and match your favorites. Keep reading to find out what your choices are. 

Pizza Toppings

From meat to cheese to vegetables, our pizza pie menu is loaded with toppings that make for the best pizzas you’ll ever eat. 

Each of the hand-baked pizzas starts with the house tomato sauce. Then the fun happens. Try the classic Fun Guy pizza with sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, and grated feta and parmesan cheese. 

Want something with meat on it? You’ll love the Wiseguy, which combines pepperoni and sausage with a delightful blend of red onions, mushrooms, and olives. 

The Fat Guy is piled with pepperoni, salami, sausage, bacon, and ham. If you have a meat craving, this pizza is sure to satisfy.

If you’re in the mood for chicken, try the Dirty Bird, which is topped with grilled chicken, tomatoes, garlic, red onions, and feta cheese. Or order the Metro Guy with spicy chicken, arugula, caramelized onions, garlic, and feta cheese. 

The vegetarian pizzas are also outstanding. Choose the Vegetablarian with its delectable blend of tomatoes, olives, red onions, mushrooms, green bell peppers, and garlic. 

Another great meat-free choice is the Margarita Guy, topped with fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil, and garlic. 

The menu also offers dairy-free mozzarella if you have food restrictions that keep you from eating regular cheese.

Unique Pizzas

The classic pizza flavors of pepperoni and cheese aren’t your only options when you eat at Pizza Pie. In addition to the traditional ingredients that everyone craves on their slice, there’s a lot more to try. 

Perhaps the most unique pizza on the menu is the White Trash Guy. The base is ranch dressing, then layered with bacon, scallions, kettle potato chips, and both Parmesan and mozzarella cheese. 

Another unique option is the BBQ Bird pizza which features, as the name implies, barbecued chicken, caramelized onions, scallions, and a tasty topping of fresh gouda cheese. 

You’re also going to love the Greek Anti-Pizza. Toppings include tomatoes, artichokes, ham, salami, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, garlic, parmesan cheese, and feta cheese. 

Don’t miss the Sad Guy, which features meatballs and gorgonzola. There’s also bacon, red onions, and tomato sauce on this unique pie. 

Of course, you can also get as unique as you want by creating your own slice. Mix and match the ingredients you love best to put together your own signature slice of pizza, no matter how crazy it might be. 

What to Eat With Your Pizza

Pizza isn’t the only thing on our pizza pie menu. You have loads of choices to complete your meal. Of course, there’s nothing wrong with having just the pizza, but if you want a little more, you have options. 

Salad pairs wonderfully with pizza. Choose the Cobb Salad with a blend of greens, chicken, bacon, eggs, and fresh gorgonzola cheese, topped with your choice of dressing. 

Another salad that makes Pizza Pie stand out is the Spinach Salad, which boasts fresh spinach, tossed with almonds, red onions, feta cheese, and a delicious raspberry vinaigrette dressing. 

There’s also a classic house salad with your choice of dressing and a fresh Caesar salad with crisp croutons and fresh parmesan cheese. 

Another classic side dish that goes with pizza is hot wings. The Pizza Pie wings are perfectly crispy, tossed with a spicy wing sauce, and served with ranch or blue cheese dressing. Choose from traditional or boneless wings. 

Cheese sticks and garlic knots are other choices that will take your pizza meal to the next level.

Sandwiches and More

Not in the mood for pizza? Try the calzones and sandwiches at Wiseguy Pizza Pie instead. The traditional calzone is packed to its gills with ricotta cheese, mozzarella, and your two favorite toppings. 

Try the meatball hoagie or the Wiseguy Cheesesteak with shaved meat, melted cheese, and crisp bell peppers. The Chicken Parm sandwich is perfectly fried and topped with a heap of melted provolone cheese. 

There’s also the Italian hoagie, piled with cold cuts, cheese, vegetables, and a tangy balsamic vinaigrette. The cheeseburger is perfect for someone who wants a classic American meal.

The menu also features a selection of soft drinks, beer, and wine to complete the meal. 

Getting the Most out of the Pizza Pie Menu

Our Pizza Pie menu is brimming with mouthwatering choices. The best thing to do is try everything at least once. Try all of your favorites, but don’t be afraid to try something new once in a while too.

Our Pizza Pie menu is available for delivery and pickup, so there’s always an easy way to have the best slice of pizza in your hands in no time. 

Check out our online menu and get ready for the pizza of a lifetime.

Leave a Reply